One step forward, two steps back. It’s downright disheartening, and you can bet that’s the objective. I’m thoroughly disgusted with Congress’s lack of responsibility and common sense. Not to mention common courtesy: for the dozens of emails, letters and phone calls I have made, I’ve yet to receive one single response. Today, I’m writing again to President Obama:

Dear Mr. President:

Like so many others, I worked hard to get you elected, and I’m thrilled that our collective efforts were fruitful. Solutions to real problems require a measured, thoughtful and reasoned assessment of myriad issues too often top-lined for the sake of media sound bites or political sparring. Your ability to both weigh and articulate complexities is one of the reasons I voted for you.

So I am asking you now to apply that skill to the very real problems with the CPSIA. This is not a business vs. children issue, as it has been portrayed. As a mother, a liberal, an environmentalist and small business owner, I welcome the new limits on harmful materials in children’s products, just as ardently as I oppose the irresponsible and destructive aspects of this law, which do not improve safety. These include:

RETROACTIVE APPLICATION OF NEW STANDARDS has created immoral and unnecessary waste, not to mention lost profits and productivity, confusion and closed businesses. Wasted unsalable new inventory and used goods. Businesses, non-profits and individuals scramble to follow the law and the CPSC’s specific directions to sequester books published before 1985, and dispose of, rather than donate or sell used clothing bearing buttons, snaps or zippers, as well as untested toys and other products. This is particularly unconscionable considering that there are no reported injuries attributed to these products. Products found to cause injury have already been recalled, and are therefore already unlawful to sell, making this completely unnecessary and shamefully wasteful.

END PRODUCT TESTING has forced small producers out of the market, ironically leaving the spoils to the same large companies – manufacturing overseas – who are guilty of the very offenses that spurred Congress to create the CPSIA in the first place. While it may seem reasonable to test each component of a completed made-in-China “Dora” doll before selling millions of them, that logic does not hold up when applied to testing each component of a completed domestic handmade dress before selling three of them. Expensive third-party testing is simply not practicable for small producers, and as their products have not been shown to be the offenders, imposing regulations that force them out of the market is unfair, un-American and considering the current economy, unwise. What does make sense, affords greater safety and efficiency, is requiring manufacturers to use CPSIA compliant materials and manufacturing processes.

I have had to close my hair accessory business because testing is simply not an attainable option for a small producer of custom products. Congress has made it painfully clear how expendable and insignificant they consider my plight through their profound lack of response to my repeated requests for CPSIA reform. But I believe my situation is representative of thousands, and worth a closer look.

If family integrity is revered at all, the entrepreneurial efforts of mothers providing their families with needed income while home caring for their children should be valued and encouraged, not ignored, disparaged, or regulated out of existence. And it goes well beyond moms like me, working from home. My local consignment shop, a 26 year old family business, has stopped selling children’s items – previously the largest portion of their sales. I’m afraid to sell my own kids’ outgrown clothing, which typically funds their next year’s wardrobe. Our school district and local library are biting their nails, waiting, hoping for reasonable reform before the stay of enforcement expires. Even many domestic manufacturers far larger than myself can’t afford to comply with testing requirements and are on the brink of collapse. Personally, I have lost my disposable income, and with it, my ability to stimulate the local economy. Multiply these experiences by tens of thousands across the country.

And while businesses hobble along, crippled by the CPSIA, close up completely, or operate unknowingly in violation (risking significant liability) Congress deflects responsibility and plays politics with the CPSC. The complete unwillingness of Democratic lawmakers to even concede there is more to the story than big business vs. children’s safety is excruciatingly disheartening to me as a liberal, forsaken by my own party.

I beg you to intervene. Please make CPSIA reform an urgent priority, for the sake of small business, consumer safety, and our children. Far more of them will be compromised by their parents’ loss of income than could ever be compromised by reading old books or wearing jeans with zippers.

Sincerely,

Jen DeGrace
Jen Lynn Designs

Please continue to make your voice heard. Only sustained and growing public outcry can possibly affect change.